Juror In ‘Loud Music’ Trial Wanted Murder Conviction

Source: Seni Tienabeso / ABC News

A juror in the controversial Florida “loud music” trial says there was no chance from the start of a murder conviction in the shooting of an unarmed teen at a gas station because several jurors were convinced Michael Dunn acted in self-defense.

Juror #4 – who asked to be identified simply as “Valerie” – told ABC News in an exclusive interview that the issue of self-defense forced the jury into an immediate deadlock and prompted some shouting matches. Two and then three jurors ultimately believed Dunn, 47, was justified in the 2012 shooting death of 17-year-old Jordan Davis. Valerie, who wanted a murder conviction, says the group knew within the first hour that they would be unable to reach a unanimous decision.

The first thing jurors did when handed the case was turn to page 25 in the jury instructions, she said. The question: Do you believe that Michael Dunn was justified or unjustified in the murder of Jordan Davis?”

“It said if he believed that he had an eminent threat to himself or his fiancee, so that was a thing that those two folks believed – he was frightened and there was no other option for him in regards to Mr. Davis,” Valerie said. “The rest of us were 100 percent sure, you didn’t have to react [with gunfire], you could have had another option.

To read this article in its entirety visit ABC News.

ABC Entertainment News|ABC Business News

  • Susan05401

    I don’t understand how any black person can live in Florida. As a minority I choose to live in a community not ruled by hatred and fear. Leave Florida, there are better people and better places in America.

    • Marc Livinlife McIntyre

      see southern florida is full of love and peace its only in mid and northern florida that you would find hatred, fear and racism.

  • LoveBRT

    Glad “Mike Dunn” at least was “convicted” on the other “four” counts!! Also… happy that “State of Florida Prosecution” will re-try” Dunn on the “1st Dregree Murder Count” of Jordan Davis!!! Mr. Davis and his family needs “JUSTICE”!! This is not the “old West in Florida” with those …. “Stand your Ground Laws”… this is crazy… now everyone in that State will be “GUN” happy… or just try to “KILL” someone that they “HATE” and have a backup plan to “cover” any charges!!! Mr. Dunn… I agree … had “OPTIONS”… to move his vehicle and roll up his “windows”… I have heard “loud” music many times that I did not like and made me feel uncomfortable as Mr. Dunn stated. I just moved my vehicle to another location or left that area!!! I DID NOT TAKE OUT A GUN TO SHOOT PEOPLE!!! ” WELL>>>> looks like the “WILD WEST” is back in FLORIDA!!